Layperson Version
Our Future
If you have gotten this far in this blog (and not cheated and jumped over a few (can II blame you???), you certainly don’t need another 10 minutes on immunology and its paradoxes. So allow me to suggest some personal and public health thoughts for you to ponder.
1. We are in a brutal evolutionary struggle between humans and microbial pathogens. The pathogens evolve much faster than we adapt. A new pathogen emerges, on average, every 4 to 5 years. Covid-19 has been bad, but the larger danger comes from a novel influenza that has a high fatality rate and is highly transmissible before the development of symptoms. There is a 1% yearly probability of an influenza pandemic that could cause six million deaths or more.
​
2. About 75% of new emerging diseases are zoonotic (originating in animals). Humans amplify that threat in a variety of ways. Our appetites are insatiable for animal protein (e.g., pigs, cows, and god forbid, wet-markets). Deforestation is bringing humans into more frequent contact with wildlife such as bats (spreading infection). It has been well documented now that popular house pets (dogs and cats) can contract and transmit the coronavirus. Scientists in the “Predict” program have discovered 1200 animal-borne diseases over the past several years and estimate there may be 700,000 more we don’t know about.
​
3. The world is “a little blue marble” and spreading disease to and from our borders in places such as Brazil, South Africa, or Britain can, as we are seeing with the coronavirus, lead to genetic variants that evade immunity, vaccine, and become potentially deadly. Fighting diseases in one country is not as effective as them being fought “everywhere.”
​
4. The U.S. government failed to provide early and adequate support for testing and contact tracing with SARS-CoV-2. It failed in a timely manner to effectively distribute medical supplies and equipment, standardize epidemic data, and enforce rational triggers for stay-at-home orders and school closings. Such errors resulted in an inadequate response to the COVID-19 pandemic (and unspeakable death). We cannot allow such errors in adherence and commitment to public health guidelines to occur again.
​
5. A large number (perhaps a majority) of Americans failed to take relatively minor preventive steps such as mask-wearing and social distancing. Part of this was because of a president who consistently played down and politicized the public health crisis. But the problem runs deeper than political ineptitude and resistance to commonsense measures. Epidemiology and public health dictate the necessity of demographic assessments of age, comorbidity, socioeconomic factors, and basic living conditions in a pandemic or for that matter, any health-related issues. How would the U.S. have behaved if political and societal actions had been more closely aligned and sensitive to these epidemiologic factors and risk of death? It requires conscientious, organized, astute, and empathetic governing to assess specific and generic risks to protect humanity.
​
6. Finally, calibrating our responses and responsibilities to the urgencies and dangers we face as a society, will protect the public health and improve the well-being of humankind in general. Attention to climate change, pollution, farming, deforestation, wildlife, health, precision health, disease prevention, and providing adequate federal planning, resources, and funding for the next pandemic is our only hope for a better future.
It is estimated that there are 380 trillion (1038) viruses residing in environmental ecosystems throughout the world. Let us all hope and pray that the bioscience, applications of immunology, genetic science, AI technologies, and mostly our personal and societal efforts will meet and defeat this public health challenge of infectious disease pandemics and will help humanity create a better place in which we and future generations all can live.
Blog #45: Epilogue ("It Takes a Village!")
So, just what is “the paradox of the immune system?” As you have probably concluded by now, the “paradox” is actually a collection of paradoxes or would-be contradictions, inconsistencies, indeed, even mysteries of medical and healthcare science involving the immune system. Just to list some, but not all that I tried to identify through the previous 44 blogs, they include:
-
  Self-versus-nonself;
-
  Innate versus adaptive immunity;
-
  Adaptive immunity as a friend and foe;
-
  Our “best friend and worst enemy”;
-
  Immunity’s regulated and dysregulated systems;
-
  Health protection and health threat;
-
  Dangerous versus benign nonself and the toll-like receptor (TLR) “sentry”;
-
  Acute inflammation healing and ulceration;
-
  Acute versus chronic inflammation;
-
  Accumulation of immune (cellular and humoral) substances in tissue;
-
  Tumor necrosis factor (TNF-a) inflammatory and anti-inflammatory effects;
-
  Self-versus-self (autoimmunity);
-
  Autoimmunity (“the mother of all immune system paradoxes”);
-
  Female versus male predilections to autoimmune diseases and cancers;
-
  Rogue B-cell attacking self;
-
  Epitope spreading;
-
  The role of the X chromosome and miRNA in males versus females;
-
  Immunosuppressive agents as therapeutics and as threats;
-
  The immune system and COVID-19 (the infection’s best friend and worst enemy).
This list only scratched the surface of the immune system puzzles. Actually, the science of immunology is growing every day and we will begin to trace its progress with each succeeding blog. I can only hope that the previous blogs have given you a contemporaneous foundation and framework upon which we can continue to build an understanding of this enigmatic science going forward. Immunology, autoimmune disease, cancer, immunotherapies and regrettably, pandemics are the kinds of subjects that need a continuing informational resource, many of which exist already in varying forms. This blog will attempt to be your source for relevant, updating of the paradoxes that will flow from evolving immunologic research. Hopefully, it will also provide some answers to the enigmatic information presented.
We are beginning to see the occasional 95-year old still jogging or the 100-year old blowing out birthday candles. It makes us feel like, “I’ve got a shot” and indeed you do. We can pretty much thank our immune system for giving us that hope. But as far as beating the “grim reaper” or immortality, we all pretty much know, “it ain’t gonna happen” in most of our lifetimes. Chronic inflammation, autoimmunity, cancer (or “cancering”), and all the other immune-related diseases are all products of “an enemy within us.” The system that defends most of us, most of our lives, is also the inescapable collaborator in our “last dance.” Best we accept that ultimate paradox of the immune system by proffering care and empathy to those who suffer its unkind duplicities as we try to enjoy and be thankful for the benefits and protection it provides.